Chapter 3 - The Fox’s Secret
Inside apartment 14B, Lily refused to let go of Natalie.
Natalie changed her into warm clothes, made hot chocolate, and sat with her on the living room rug. The orange stuffed fox remained pressed between them.
Natalie did not demand answers. She asked small, gentle questions and allowed long silences.
Gradually, the story emerged.
Evelyn had collected Lily from preschool the previous afternoon. Instead of bringing her home, she took her to Melissa’s apartment. They asked Lily whether she wanted to live with Grandma forever.
When Lily said she wanted her mother, Evelyn became angry.
That morning, Evelyn brought her back to the Halston and told her to wear pajamas so the police would believe Natalie had left her alone overnight.
Melissa had removed Lily’s shoes before they entered the lobby.
“They said I had to cry,” Lily whispered.
Natalie struggled to keep her voice calm.
“Did Aunt Melissa say that too?”
Lily nodded.
“But Aunt Melissa said she was sorry when Grandma went downstairs.”
Lily turned the stuffed fox around. A small seam near its back had been cut and roughly repaired.
“Grandma put something inside Felix.”
Natalie carefully opened the seam.
A tiny black voice recorder slid into her palm.
For several seconds, Natalie could only stare at it.
Evelyn had hidden a recording device inside a child’s toy.
Whether she intended to record Natalie’s private conversations, manufacture evidence, or monitor Lily, Natalie did not yet know.
She placed the device inside a clean envelope without pressing any buttons.
Then she called Rebecca Sloan, an attorney she had met through work.
Rebecca listened without interruption.
“Do not contact your mother tonight,” she said. “Save every message. Photograph the device where you found it. Email yourself a timeline while the details are fresh. Tomorrow morning, we secure your daughter’s documents and financial accounts.”
“Financial accounts?”
“People usually create false custody claims for one of three reasons,” Rebecca said. “Control, revenge, or money. With your mother, we should assume all three.”
Natalie looked at Lily, who had fallen asleep against her side.
Two years earlier, Lily’s father had died after a sudden illness. He had left their daughter a protected trust worth more than two million dollars.
Only Natalie and the appointed trustee were supposed to know the details.
May you like
But Evelyn had helped organize the funeral paperwork.
She might have seen everything.
