Chapter 6 - Anna Voss
Anna Voss lived in a small town near the Vermont border and worked night shifts at a rehabilitation hospital. Detective Reed coordinated with local authorities, but Emily insisted on going. Rachel came with her, carrying copies of the photographs, the witness statement, and Caroline’s letter.
They found Anna outside the hospital at seven in the morning. She wore navy scrubs beneath a gray coat and held a paper cup of coffee between both hands. Her hair was darker than Emily remembered Ava’s, but the eyes were the same. So was the scar above her left eyebrow.
Emily stopped ten feet away.
Anna noticed the officers first, then Rachel, then Emily. Her expression shifted from confusion to fear.
“Anna Voss?” Reed asked.
“Yes.”
“My name is Detective Samuel Reed. We need to speak with you about your childhood.”
Anna took one step backward. “My mother warned me this could happen.”
Emily’s throat tightened. “Who is your mother?”
“Diane Carter.”
The answer made no sense until Anna explained.
She had been raised by a couple named Peter and Elise Voss, who told her she was adopted after being abandoned at a hospital. Diane visited twice a year and introduced herself as Aunt Diane, a family friend who had arranged the adoption. She paid school fees, medical bills, and later nursing tuition. When Anna questioned missing documents, Diane said Anna’s biological mother had been dangerous and unstable.
Three weeks earlier, Diane called to say strangers might claim to be Anna’s family. She warned that Emily Carter was delusional and obsessed with a drowned sister.
Anna looked at Emily with guarded pity. “She showed me articles about you leaving your husband.”
Emily did not defend herself. She handed Anna a childhood photograph taken beside the river. Two girls wore matching red mittens. Ava had lost one during the picnic. Emily still had the other in a memory box.
Anna stared at the image.
“I’ve dreamed about that coat,” she whispered.
They moved to a private room inside the hospital. Rachel explained the evidence without forcing conclusions. Reed offered a voluntary DNA test. Anna refused at first, then asked to see Caroline’s letter.
Halfway through reading it, she began to cry.
“My adoptive parents died in a car accident when I was seventeen,” she said. “Diane handled everything after that. She told me there was no other family.”
Emily sat across from her, afraid that reaching out would feel like a demand. “You don’t owe me anything. Not belief. Not a relationship. Not even the test. I only wanted you to know someone looked for you every day.”
Anna raised her eyes. “Did you?”
Emily answered honestly. “I was a child. Then I believed what adults told me. But my mother never stopped.”
Anna agreed to the test.
The preliminary result confirmed a sibling relationship with overwhelming probability. A formal laboratory analysis would follow, but no one in the room needed it.
Emily and Anna did not embrace immediately. They sat in silence, studying each other across the years that had been stolen from them.
Then Anna asked, “Why would Diane take me?”
The answer emerged from Caroline’s files. Ava, not Emily, had been the primary beneficiary of their grandfather’s trust because she was born after a revision to his will. If Ava died, her share passed to Emily. If Emily were later declared incompetent, a court-appointed guardian could control the entire estate.
Diane had hidden Ava alive rather than risk an investigation into a child’s death. She used false adoption documents, funded the Voss family, and waited for Caroline to stop searching. When Caroline came close, Robert Carter intervened.
The Carters had spent twenty-four years trying to control money that never belonged to them.
Anna’s phone rang while they reviewed the documents. The caller ID showed Diane.
Reed signaled for everyone to remain quiet and began recording.
Anna answered.
Diane’s voice was warm. “Sweetheart, I heard strangers came to your work.”
Anna looked at Emily. “They say my name was Ava Vale.”
A pause.
Then Diane’s tone changed.
“Listen carefully. Emily will destroy your life the way her mother destroyed everyone around her. Leave the hospital through the west stairwell. A car is waiting.”
“Where will it take me?”
“To your father.”
Anna’s hand tightened around the phone. “Peter Voss is dead.”
Diane whispered, “I don’t mean Peter.”
The call ended.
Seconds later, an alarm sounded in the parking garage. A black SUV crashed through the exit barrier and sped away.
Inside the stairwell, officers found a sedative-filled syringe, a wheelchair, and a photograph of Anna taken that morning.
On the back was the same handwriting as the message in Emily’s envelope.
But this time the warning was different:
ROBERT CARTER WANTS BOTH DAUGHTERS ALIVE.
The first hours with Anna were not the reunion Emily had imagined as a child. There was no instant restoration, no embrace powerful enough to erase twenty-four years. They asked careful questions and sometimes stopped when the answers became too heavy.
May you like
Anna remembered a lullaby but not Caroline’s face. She remembered being called Ava during nightmares, then being punished for insisting it was her real name. She remembered Diane bringing red mittens every winter even after she had outgrown them.
Emily understood that Diane had not only hidden Anna. She had repeatedly tested whether the old identity remained alive.
